Skip to main content
Commonweal

Commonweal

Magazine | United States | Centre-Left
www.commonwealmagazine.org/

Liberal Catholic magazine offering independent commentary on religion, politics, and culture.

Engagement Insights

98
Discussions
0
Participants
0
Total Votes
124
Articles

Discussions from Commonweal

Geopolitics

On Dubious Analogies

On Dubious Analogies President Trump’s supporters have offered some implausible scenarios on the likely outcome of his war of choice with Iran, as well as some wild justifications for it. But the most bizarre justification I’ve come across appears in Francis X. Maier’s essay “On Doing the Right Thing,” published by The Catholic Thing. Trump’s determination to destroy Iran’s supposed nuclear threat and its theocratic tyranny is justified, Maier believes, for the same reason that Lutheran theol...

United States
Join Discussion
Politics

In Praise of a Political Church

In Praise of a Political Church In the war of words between Pope Leo and President Donald Trump last week, the two U.S.-born world leaders seemed to agree on only one thing: that the pope is not a politician. In the rambling Truth Social post that started the ruckus, Trump accused Leo of supporting crime, a nuclear Iran, and Venezuelan drug dealers, while also taking credit for the pope’s election and getting in a dig that he prefers Leo’s MAGA brother. But he concluded the rant by advising L...

United States
Join Discussion
Geopolitics

Slouching Toward Beirut

Slouching Toward Beirut On November 30, 2025, Pope Leo began a three-day visit to Lebanon. A papal visit had been long in the planning. Pope Francis had wanted to go to Lebanon but was prevented from doing so—first for security concerns and then because of failing health. When Pope Leo arrived in Beirut, he was greeted like a rock star. Jubilant crowds braved torrential rains to welcome him. It was exceptional, even by Lebanese standards. After meeting with government officials and Christian ...

Lebanon
Join Discussion
Society

Get Conversion Therapy Out of the Church

Get Conversion Therapy Out of the Church When the U.S. Supreme Court struck down Colorado’s ban on conversion therapy last month, I immediately thought of Alana Chen, a twenty-four-year-old Catholic woman who died by suicide in 2019 after counseling from priests and other Catholic leaders about her homosexuality. I had worked with Alana’s mom, Joyce Calvo, to publish her essay pleading with Church leaders to protect LGBTQ Catholics from the dangerous practice of conversion therapy. Chen’s sto...

United States
Join Discussion
Culture

The Roots Conversation Series

The Roots Conversation Series The Roots conversation series is a collaboration between Columbia’s Burke Library at Union Theological Seminary and Commonweal. It convenes a range of thinkers for a series of public discussions grounded in philosophy, theology, and the humanities. The aim is not to defend specific positions or provide inarguable conclusions. Instead we seek to invite reflection, provoke conversation, and inspire action—a mode of meeting the political, moral, and existential chal...

United States
Join Discussion
Technology

The Rise of the Catholic Chatbot

The article explores the emergence of AI chatbots within the Catholic community, examining their potential to engage believers and facilitate discussions on faith in the digital age.

United States
Join Discussion
Culture

Preaching the Seven Last Words

Preaching the Seven Last Words The following meditations on the Seven Last Words of Christ were delivered at the Cathedral of Saint Matthew the Apostle in Washington D.C. on Good Friday, 2025. Each meditation was followed by a musical interlude sung by the choir. Preaching on the Seven Last Words is not part of the Good Friday liturgy. It has instead been traditionally part of the Three Hours Devotion on Good Friday, a practice begun in Lima by the Peruvian Jesuit Alonso Mesia (1665–1732), a ...

United States
Join Discussion
Culture

Why Do We Persevere?

Why Do We Persevere? When we ask for Mary to guide us, we should be prepared. The journey might be inconvenient, rainy, freezing cold, dangerous. Sometimes Mary brings us to the foot of the cross, sometimes to the gates of ICE detention. I pray the rosary at my parish on Tuesday mornings with a remarkable group of women. We convened fifteen years ago—young, weary, overworked moms, desperate for community and support. Most of us thought the rosary was for old ladies. Now, I’m pretty sure we ar...

United States
Join Discussion
Culture

All the Way to the Abyss

All the Way to the Abyss “[T]he way of the cross is traced close to the earth. The mighty withdraw from it; they desire to grasp at heaven. Yet heaven is here below; it hangs low, and we can encounter it even when we fall flat on the ground. Today’s builders of Babel tell us that there is no room for losers, and that those who fall along the way are losers. Theirs is the construction site of Hell. God’s economy, on the other hand, does not kill, discard or crush. It is lowly, faithful to the ...

Global
Join Discussion
Politics

Fight for the Fourteenth

Fight for the Fourteenth The U.S. bishops remain divided about many issues, but immigration is not, for the most part, one of them. Their special message against mass deportations passed overwhelmingly last November, and bishops across the ideological spectrum have publicly expressed concern about immigration enforcement that has crossed moral and legal lines. But Catholics on the right don’t always agree with their religious leaders on this issue, as evidenced by the reaction to a recent ami...

United States
Join Discussion
Culture

Poem | The Encounter

Poem | The Encounter I saw Jesus today. A figure bent hobbled disheveled, clinging to a rickety walker, shuffling toward reception, needing help or a kind word. Wavering, I offered neither. I saw Jesus today. And I passed him by. James Hannan March 23, 2026

United States
Join Discussion
Culture

Wittgenstein’s Apocalypse

Wittgenstein’s Apocalypse “It isn’t absurd,” the philosopher Ludwig Wittgenstein wrote in 1947, “to believe that the age of science and technology is the beginning of the end for humanity.” The proposition is looking less absurd by the day: AI may eventually turn on us; industrialization has turned the planet against us; social media is turning us against each other; and nuclear weapons linger just offstage, waiting for another turn. What Wittgenstein—and the many other Romantically inclined ...

Global
Join Discussion